Thursday, April 30, 2026

The "God given find" principle in production sharing agreements

The discovery and discovery of new deposits with promising reserves is a public good.

However, this opinion is not shared by everyone.

Below is a short story based on true events.

History knows cases when the "right to conclude a production sharing agreement" was the subject of lobbying from both commercial circles and energy ministries, and information about the deposit and reserves in promising areas was considered so secret that during the clarification of the circumstances, the phrase "God given find" was born.

Interstate sought the relief  of carrying out its drilling programmes in Turkana and West Pokot areas of the Rift Valley (Kenya) to prospect for water for the local communities, it (at the time it was known as Interstate Mining Co. Ltd) had encountered “a black substance smelling like kerosene” which it suspected “to be crude oil”. 

That it then provided the Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of Energy with samples of that substance in December 2005 with a request to carry out chemical analysis; that thereafter, it applied to the Permanent Secretary to be issued with a non exclusive exploration permit with a view to obtaining further crude samples for further chemical analysis and with a view also to undertaking crude reserve quantification feasibility report as a foundation for a production sharing contract with the Ministry of Energy and its overseas strategic investors.  

The Minister of Energy claimed of its “God given find” in that, using Interstate’s samples, the Minister “deceitfully andfraudulently” expropriated and misappropriated its secrets and “clandestinely” issued exploration permit  to the interested parties (Court of Appeal at Eldoret, Civil appeal № 376 of 2014).

Qualification costs in production sharing agreements. Kenya's experience for Ukraine

In Ukraine, capital expenditures of investors under production sharing agreements are understood as expenses for the implementation of work programs and budgets and their associated costs, which are subject to taxation and at the same time a reverse charge for the reimbursement of investors' tax expenses.

However, in Nigerian tax law, "qualifying expenses" are treated as capital expenditure, other than intangible drilling costs, incurred in the operation of the petroleum company.

Where an assignment of a right under a petroleum agreement involves the disposal of assets which represent qualifying expediture not yet allowed against income.

Where the assignment is of part only of the rights held by the petroleum company or where not all the essets which represent qualifying expenditure are included in the assignment, the amount of qualifying not yet allowed against income which is to be deducted from the consideration for the assignment shall be apportioned by the commissioner.

Drilling cost are not forming part of qualifiyng expenditure and only qulifying expenditure was to be deducted from the consideration.

Where a taxpayer has faiiled to submit a tax return for a reporting period in accordance with the provision of the tax law, the Commissioner may based on such information as may be available and to the best of his/her judgment (Republic of Kenya in the tax appelas tribunal № 347 of 2018).

That is, Kenya retains autonomy in differentiating overhead costs.

Of course, it would be logical to review overhead costs in the context of "qualification costs", however, in our opinion, this would hamper the investment attractiveness of the production sharing agreement.

Sunday, April 26, 2026

Technologically altered deposits in production areas transferred for the purposes of production sharing agreements

Technogenically altered deposits are rock deposits that have been damaged by previously passed mining operations, which make it impossible to use traditional methods of geological exploration, such as trenching and drilling wells and pits. 

To study altered deposits, a hydromechanized method of sinking pits is used.

A simpler explanation is that it is extracted underground through disintegration and destruction of the productive rock layer or by leaching rocks with the mineral being brought to the surface.

That is, signs of hydrolysis or disintegration applied to the deposit site indicate that the site was developed through existing geological exploration projects or illegal mining was carried out on the site before the site was included in the competition for the conclusion of a production sharing agreement.

How to avoid problems with obtaining a plot under a production sharing agreement?

One effective way to protect investors' rights is to prepare an environmental impact assessment report, which can later be used when approving or revising mineral reserves.

The results of the environmental impact assessment report cannot be ignored by the authorized authorities, in addition, information about illegal mining cannot be hidden from the public participating in the consideration of this report.

It is prohibited to conduct economic activities, operate facilities, and other interventions in the natural environment and landscapes, including the extraction of minerals, the use of man-made mineral deposits, unless full compliance with the environmental conditions provided for in the environmental impact assessment report, the decision on the implementation of the planned activity, and the projects for construction, expansion, re-profiling, liquidation (dismantling) of facilities, other interventions in the natural environment and landscapes, including the extraction of minerals, the use of man-made mineral deposits, as well as changes in this activity or extension of the terms of its implementation are ensured.

The environmental impact assessment report, public discussion report and environmental impact assessment conclusion are submitted by the business entity to obtain a decision from a state authority or local government body on the implementation of the planned activity, which is the basis for the commencement of this activity, establishes (approves) the parameters and conditions for the implementation of the planned activity and is adopted in the form of a permit document or other act of a state authority or local government body in accordance with the procedure established by law for relevant decisions.

If provided for in the environmental impact assessment report, the business entity shall ensure that post-project monitoring is carried out to identify any discrepancies and deviations in the predicted levels of impact and the effectiveness of measures to prevent and reduce environmental pollution.

If, during the implementation of an economic activity for which an environmental impact assessment was carried out, a significant negative impact of this activity on the life and health of the population or the environment is detected, and if such impact was not assessed during the environmental impact assessment and/or significantly changes the results of the environmental impact assessment of this activity, the decision to carry out such planned activity shall be subject to cancellation by a court decision, and the activity shall be terminated.

That is, the balance of the investor's rights under the production sharing agreement and the rights of the state is preserved.

So, a man-made altered site for the investor can become:

1) a source of compensation for losses;

2) a basis for revising work programs and budgets;

3) a revision of the volume of approved mineral reserves on the site.

Saturday, April 18, 2026

Selection of a contractor for work in production sharing agreements

The correctness of accounting for investors' expenses in production sharing agreements is directly related to the terms of the production sharing agreement itself.

Production sharing agreements impose obligations not only personally on the state representative in this agreement or on the investor, but also on the specifics of the performance and conduct of contract work under the production sharing agreement.

That is, subcontracting work in geological tasks becomes important from the point of view of the overall assessment of the activities of a particular investor.

In addition, the investor, regardless of his capabilities, cannot fully ensure the implementation of the full cycle of work at all stages of production, therefore the role and importance of the contractor under the production sharing agreement actually acquires a new meaning.

In the Small Mining Encyclopedia of Ukraine, mining is understood as the extraction of minerals as an action, a process of extracting minerals from the subsoil as a result of their development: solid minerals by underground and open pit methods, gaseous gushing and pumping from evaporation solutions or other methods.

In the process of such extraction, the contractor guarantees that the work will be performed by qualified personnel, and also certifies that the contractor has the necessary equipment, permits, and documentation for the equipment.

That is, the investor "correctly" wins in the position when he successfully chose the contracting organization:

1) the investor can count on full reimbursement of all costs;

2) the investor has the opportunity to legally delegate powers under the production sharing agreement with contractors, freeing himself from the financial burden of obtaining regulatory permits and saving money.

The same as choosing a contractor in a production sharing agreement.

This is best done by forming a technical task in a contract for the performance of works.

The technical task, as a rule, should be drawn up with the following mandatory details:

1) name of the deposit and its location;

2) geological study;

3) degree of geological exploration;

4) basis - special permit for the use of subsoil;

5) characteristics of the enterprise and its raw material base;

6) description of the extraction sites.

In this case, the contractor provides:

 - qualified personnel to perform all types of work; 

 - mobilization of equipment and materials and personnel at the work site; 

 - compliance of the equipment with the technical and technological conditions;

- working condition of the equipment.

Tuesday, April 14, 2026

Assessment of the effectiveness of the implementation of the 5-year Geological Survey Program in production sharing agreements

It is advisable to economically evaluate the geological study program in production sharing agreements by cost categories.

1. Category. Seismic and its implementation status: 

1) seismic data processing; 
2) interpretation of seismic surveys; 
3) design according to profiles and geological; 
4) certification and expertise;
5) initial resource base.

2. Category. Basin modeling: 

1) core material research; 
2) regional geological assessment; 
3) well exploration and restoration; 
4) development of groundwater basin design documentation.

3. Exploration stage. Drilling of new wells (number to be specified)

4. Exploration and geological study:

a) percentage of planned costs; 
b) percentage of actual costs.

5. Ecology and environment:

a) percentage of planned costs; 
b) percentage of actual costs.

6. General and administrative expenses:

a) percentage of planned costs; 
b) percentage of actual costs.

7. Share of investments made over 5 years

a) payment of bonuses; 
b) payment of premiums; 
c) payment of social investment costs.

Having summarized the data, it is advisable to combine them into one table in order to calculate the dynamics of the geological study program, since the share of construction in the items of expenses for geological works can equalize the proportionality of general and administrative expenses incurred by investors. 

The larger the amounts of expenses, the more difficult it is to summarize approximately single indicators of efficiency, because the share of expenses in the items of the geological works budget program could vary significantly in any one of 5 years.

In addition, investor reporting data on production sharing agreements is more fragmented.

Sunday, April 12, 2026

Impact of prolonged force majeure on the operation of production sharing agreements

The era of development of production sharing agreements for Ukraine began in 2021, when the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine concluded a significant number of production sharing agreements.

The Russian invasion of Ukraine has made serious adjustments to the planning and implementation of hydrocarbon production projects under production sharing agreements.

Foreign, including domestic, investors declared force majeure.

However, neither those nor the other investors could have imagined that the phase of the Russian-Ukrainian war would cross the psychological mark of 4 years.

Ukrainian investors managed to reorganize and determine the list of project tasks at the fields, at least in terms of office work, which cannot be said about foreign investors.

Foreign investors are in deep force majeure.

It is fair to note in this regard the flexibility of domestic subsoil users.

However, the purpose of this article is not to compare investors, but to address the problem that needs to be solved.

The longer the force majeure period, the more money and project cycle time and budgets are lost.

The idea of ​​the institution of force majeure is to exempt from fulfilling obligations, avoid long-term sanctions and prevent financial losses.

The main feature is that force majeure was perceived as a short-term phenomenon.

Every production sharing agreement, like any investment agreement, contains a time limit for the validity of an unspecified factor that makes it impossible to fulfill the provisions of its agreement.

In the modern Ukrainian realities of the Russian-Ukrainian war, a logical question arises: what to do next?

Understanding the Ukrainian establishment and mentality, it can be argued that:

1) The Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine will not initiate the termination of the production sharing agreement;

2) The Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine will rather agree to conclude an additional agreement to extend the term of the production sharing agreement for the time that has passed under the legal regime of martial law.

It is impossible to predict the duration of the Russian-Ukrainian war, just as it is impossible to monitor the Russian Federation's compliance with the ceasefire conditions.

That is why it is advisable for foreign investors to consider the possibility of overcoming force majeure and carrying out geological exploration work in those areas of the field where this is possible.

Several Ukrainian investors have taken a step into the unknown and have been mining for more than 2 years.

Tuesday, April 7, 2026

Geological study and geological study work? What is the difference?

The content of geological study is known through the list of works it covers. 

Paradoxically, "geological study" as a process is not identical with the concept of "geological works", which characterize it.

The Supreme Court of Ukraine tried to find the difference.

As stated in the Supreme Court resolution of December 3, 2021 in case No. 0640/4277/18, geological exploration, as a type of subsoil use based on a special permit for subsoil use, should be distinguished from works and research related to the geological study of subsoil, which are registered with the State Service for Geology and Subsoil Use of Ukraine.

State registration of works is one of the stages of obtaining in the future a special permit for the use of subsoil for the purpose of geological study, including experimental and industrial development of the deposit.

State registration is subject to work carried out on the basis, in particular, of a conclusion on the feasibility of distributing previously approved mineral reserves of a deposit (site) into separate subsoil use objects, approved in accordance with the established procedure.

How important is this clarification for investors in the context of implementing production sharing agreements?

The above formulation is a cornerstone in contractual practice, as production sharing agreements specify the components of geological exploration.

"Geological Exploration" means activities for the purpose of geological study, search and exploration for previously undiscovered hydrocarbons in the contract area, including:

 -drilling of seismic wells;
- structural wells and stratigraphic testing and drilling;
- completion and testing of exploration, Appraisal wells, pressure wells and other wells; 
- geological, geochemical, geophysical and other research and studies and their interpretation; 
- any experimental and industrial development and experimental and industrial development projects using bush drilling technology, purchase or acquisition of goods, materials, services and equipment for the above.

The wording "geological study" in the production sharing agreement significantly reduces the "list of geological study works", however, Investors have the opportunity to make changes to the Work Programs and Budget, thereby eliminating the risks of interpretations of subsoil use case law.

Saturday, April 4, 2026

The problem of overlaying geographical coordinates of other users on a plot under a production sharing agreement

During the preparation of the competition for the conclusion of production sharing agreements, the initiators of the competition verify the data of the situational plan of the intersection of the areas of adjacent plots.

The situation is particularly complicated by the registration of subsoil users of adjacent areas, who operate, as a rule, under a special permit, in the list of geological works of the geological study program.

Given that the manager of geological information for mapping and plotting pivot points enters information or transfers information manually, such cases are possible for unintentional reasons.

What should be done in such a case if a competition for the conclusion of production sharing agreements has already been announced, but an error in the coordinates of the corner points has just been discovered?

Encroachment on the coordinates of the tender documentation for the production sharing agreement to other subsoil users immediately leads to losses.

Both subsoil users and competitors in production sharing agreements bear losses to the same extent. In the first case, the losses are associated with the payment for a special permit, while for competitors in production sharing agreements, the losses occur at the stage of payment for participation in the competition for the conclusion of a production sharing agreement.

 The Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine, not wanting to violate the rights of other subsoil users, acts in two directions: 

1) cancels the resolution announcing the tender for the conclusion of production sharing agreements; 

2) makes changes to the technical description of the land plot in the annex to the tender documentation by adopting a separate resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine.

This is due to the fact that there are regulatory restrictions on the possibility of conducting geological exploration and extraction of minerals within the same subsoil area. 

Within the same subsoil area, geological exploration and extraction of various types of minerals can be carried out under several permits. 

In this case, the subsoil use agreement determines the spatial boundaries and coordinates of each type of mineral.

The package of auction documentation for mining under a special permit is documents prepared by the State Service for Geology and Mineral Resources and containing information about the subsoil area, the permit within which is put up for auction (name and coordinates, location, general information about the geological structure, initial lot price, work program), a draft agreement on the terms of subsoil use.

The announcement of the auction is placed by the State Service for Geology and Mineral Resources in the electronic bidding system for the sale of permits and on the official website of the State Service for Geology and Mineral Resources within 10 working days from the date of the decision to hold the auction.

Tips for potential investors on how to avoid problems with the imposition of corner points on the special permit of other subsoil users: 

1) check the codes of administrative-territorial units (facts of errors have already been recorded); 

2) obtain extracts from the land cadastre for information on boundary marks on land plots; 

3) send requests to local governments for information about companies that conduct drilling within the district; 

4) contact the geological information manager for additional data about the site; 

5) check the register of special permits.

Design of pilot-industrial field development

Based on the approved technological indicators for the field development, project documents are prepared for its development (up to 5 years)...