In the Russian Federation, 3 production sharing agreement projects were implemented (Sakhalin-1, Sakhalin-2, Kharagin field).
I couldn't find any positive reviews about successful project launches, unlike six available sources that claim the opposite.
In the course of analyzing Russian specialized literature devoted to the issues of production sharing agreements, such a trend is noticeable.
Here are some of them.
1. Production sharing agreements are a public-private partnership. For example, Ukrainian legislation doesn’t include production sharing agreements in the list of public-private partnership projects. The focus of public-private partnerships is on concessions, leases, and the construction of communication, logistics, and retail infrastructure. Even though the production sharing agreement model is a form of public-private partnership, it is separated by law.
2. Production sharing agreements are civil agreements. It's quite controversial and ambiguous; production sharing agreements are more of an investment instrument of commercial law than a civil law institution. Even Russian researchers note a significant difference in the functionalities of commercial and civil law institutions.
3. Production sharing agreements are the basic foundation of tripartite arrangements among federation entities to support the local population and carry out social and cultural projects. The production sharing agreement mostly works according to work programs and budgets, rather than individual agreements, which may not be part of the appendices to the production sharing agreement.
4. Production sharing agreements are the financing of both parties through an Investment Fund. The state participates in managing the agreement by selecting project works and programs through the Investment Fund. Obviously, the Russian Federation somehow controls and influences foreign capital.
5. Production sharing agreements are all about optimizing taxes. For foreign investors, it might not be profitable to charge rent or profit fees on all the raw materials while officially having their main office registered abroad, which affects the taxation of transactional operations. At the same time, for Russian financial institutions, production sharing agreements are a way to lower VAT and income tax.
6. In production sharing agreements, the state's share is smaller (10% and 90% to the investor). The imbalance in the share distributed between the parties to the production sharing agreement comes down to the fact that, after a technical and economic assessment of the fields, it is possible that the volume of extracted raw materials will not cover the costs of extraction. Hi, projects Sakhalin-1 and Sakhalin-2.
7. Production sharing agreements are a disaster for the environment. The lack of reclamation and conservation, and the absence of waste recycling operations are the result of neglect.
8. Production sharing agreements are about localizing Russian production with more than 50% quota and using labor and equipment of Russian origin for more than 70%. Obviously, Russians see the investor as the main employer in production sharing agreements, but the stated localization percentages don’t meet the expectations of the Russian industry, which is only 35% adapted to production sharing agreements.
I'm attaching a description of Russian scientific works here.
1. Tysiachniouk, Maria, Henry, Laura A., Lamers, Machiel, Tatenhove, Jan P.M van. Oil and indigenous people in sub-Arctic Russia//Rethinking equity and governance in benefit sharing agreements.
2. N.V. Sigitova. Economical and legal mechanizm for the production sharing agreements//National Mineral Resources University "Mining", Saint Petersburg, 2013.
3. Kharagezov K. V., Sbitnev V. S. Production Sharing Agreement: Problems of Theory and Practice// Sphere of Law. 2020.
4. Zershchikova N.I. Features of the Application of Production Sharing Agreements in Russia// PROBLEMS OF EXTENDED REPRODUCTION, 2008.
5. Isaev N.V. Problems of product sharing agreements legal regulation// Bulletin of Volga University named after V.N. Tatishchev No. 2.
6. Irina Glazyrina, Sergey Lavlinskii. Transaction Costs and Prospects for Public-private Partnership in the Russian Mineral Resource Sector // International Journal of Economics and Finance, 2017
________________________________________________________________________________
The article was written amid intense missile and drone attacks on electricity, gas, heating, water supply, and sewage facilities, as well as attacks on civilian bridges during the autumn-winter period in Kyiv and other regions of Ukraine.
In the memory of the fallen Ukrainian civilians and soldiers