Saturday, May 30, 2026

Net cash flow forecast under PSA

The main models of optimization and economic measures under the Production Sharing Agreement in terms of their content are: 

1) preferential royalties (a package of bonuses from the state or from payable one of the investor's side as commitments); 

2) currency restrictions and currency control; 

3) corporate tax rate; 

4) rent rate and fiscal burdens.

However, the listed components provide a good baseline scenario for the monetary valuation of the PSA and the percentage of investment attractiveness of the project.

The above baseline monetary scenario is best illustrated in the following sequence:

1) choose a time indicator in terms of PSA years; 

2) volume of extracted products; 

3) gross income after deduction of taxes and fees; 

4) royalty percentage (own and state); 

5) group of intangible assets and their value; 

6) capital expenditures; 

7) operating expenses; 

8) the cost of raw materials on the market; 

9) tax expenses (profit tax, value added tax).

It is optimal to group the described indicators into one table.

A similar scenario development of cash flow assessment is often used in the assessment of concession projects, which demonstrates the equity of property investment in the implementation of projects.

Friday, May 22, 2026

Monetary expression of the attractiveness of production sharing agreements

Calculating the costs of investors in production sharing agreements is as important as the economic assessment of their attractiveness.

Despite the fact that the primary basis of production sharing agreements is an asset in the form of subsoil, it is impossible to mathematically calculate their equivalent in a monetary unit with any degree of accuracy.

There are many economic studies on the structure of PSA in the profit scale, but none of them can come close to the truth. All the component formulas and their compositions are too approximate.

The PSA cash flow calculations of the authorized body for conducting production sharing agreements are also approximate.

Currently, the following are taken into account:

- budget reserve of programs;

- cost of mastered work cycles;

- amount of administrative expenses;

- amount of bonuses and premiums paid by investors;

- amount of budgets of socio-economic programs;

- amount of rent payments.

In my opinion, the components of the monetary valuation of PSA look somewhat primitive, so it is advisable to refer to sources of fiscal ranking in the mineral sector.

That is why, a more realistic formula for the monetary expression of PSA is best proposed by Mazeel 2010 from the Concessions Research.

1. Grooss revenue = equal profit.

2. Net revenue = total account (gross revenue minus royalty or payment).

3. Taxable income =gross revenue minus royalties.

4. Deductions (includes:

а) operational costs;

b) intangible capital costs;

c) depreciation;

d) investment (credits);

e) bonuses;

f) tax losses carried forward.

The only omission of this formula, in my opinion, is:

1) the return of value-added tax and income tax from the budget;

2) the lack of a coefficient for the market sale of minerals, since the cash flow assessment is incomplete.

Saturday, May 16, 2026

Product Sharing Agreement against Risk Service Agreement

The first modern production sharing agreement is considered to be the agreement signed in 1966 between the state-owned Indonesian company Permina.

Since then, challenges regarding the aspect of the risk under study, which, on the one hand, ensured systematic investment in hydrocarbon production, and on the other hand, contributed to the return of a fair share to investors, remain unresolved.

The first risk arises around the maximum valuation of the profit share.

The second risk is that the volatile price of hydrocarbon raw materials provides price instability, especially when there is a global price drop.

The third risk is the overestimation of hydrocarbon reserves as part of natural deposits.

The fourth risk is an imposed global model of mutual relations between not one but several investors through their joint participation in a production sharing agreement (India, Malaysia, Gambia, Nigeria, Egypt, Angola, Trinidad and Tobago, Brazil).

The fifth risk is the state's failure to reimburse the costs of hydrocarbon production.

If the fifth risk is less significant, the first four risks are not devoid of significant economic concern.

In general, experts always see the following risks in production sharing agreements: 

1) delivery of risk capital; 

2) rent payment; 

3) royalties; 

4) bonuses; 

5) taxes; 

6) local content benefits.

In order to find the optimal form for reducing risk, hydrocarbon extraction practitioners (especially in the oil and gas sector) have proposed a new type of agreement called a Risk Service Agreement.

The content of the Risk Service Agreement is that the beneficiary of natural resources (the state) pays a fixed amount for search, exploration, and industrial development in a certain percentage ratio.

A type of Risk Service Arrangements is Pure Service Agreements, Technical Assistance Agreement.

That is, the subsoil user does not claim a share in any form during commercial discovery of the deposit.

In our opinion, Risk Service Agreements have less impact on the mining market.

How do Risk Service Agreements lose to PSA?

It is possible to distinguish three strong foundations of PSA strength: 

1) the subsoil user is a participant in the raw materials market and the secondary raw materials processing market; 

2) the subsoil user retains and increases its ownership share in hydrocarbons;

3) the subsoil user forms a portfolio of minerals during production.

Sunday, May 10, 2026

Farm-out agreement in the context of production sharing agreements. Tax risks, Kenyan experience

In previous publications, we have considered the topic of investment ''shares'' of two companies in a production sharing agreement. 

Then we concluded that the role of shares is an ideal form of management sharing between two investors in a production sharing agreement has no legal significance.

However, as practice shows, the topic of investors' "shares" in production sharing agreements is not only inexhaustible, but also acquires new legal forms in complex operational structures.

In some cases, the experience of Kenya may be useful for a general understanding of the issue of "shares". Thus, the "agreement on investors' shares in a production-sharing deal" in Kenya is called a "Farm-out agreement".

Farm-out agreements are not subject to VAT. 

This position is consistent with the legislation on production sharing agreements in countries such as the United Kingdom, Malaysia, Tanzania, Ghana and Uganda.

The main postulates (principles) of the Farm-out agreement exemption from taxation are:

 - disposal of interest is not a disposal of capital assets of business, and therefore excluded in calculating the VAT registration threshold;

 - treating an interest in license as trading stock; - disposal of trading stock not excluded in calculating the VAT registration threshold;

 - amount to tax having assessed the gross cost from the Farm-out agreement instead of the amount that was to be carried and additionally charging interest for the wrong period.

That is, in the business of the exploration, development, production and exploitation of oil and gas up to the point where it is able to commercially produce oil for sale it is principal business activities and not for the purpose of resale for profit.

It can be summarised that the legislative approach of the countries listed above is that the property interest in a production sharing agreement is not subject to taxation, and the Farm-out agreement is rather a form of transfer of such property interest.

As you might guess, exemption from VAT on Farm-out agreements is not an international practice, as evidenced by Kenyan legislation and the case law of this country.

The Kenya Revenue Authority considers Farm-out agreements as separate VAT agreements on the following grounds: 

1) all mineral resources are owned by the Government of Kenya, nor the holder in PSA; 

2) transfer license (Farm-out agreement) is a taxable supply of capital nature; 

3) business is run as joint venture and each party if free to manage it is interest, but business of exploring, appraising, developing and the production of oil by virtue of having been awarded a license interest.

This opinion is also supported by judicial practice.

Farm-out constitutes a taxable supply of capital assets, not should be based on evidence and that the character of transaction must depend on the total impression (Mociian Ltd vs the Commissioner of Domestic Taxes, Appeal # 12 of 2016, Tullow Kenia B.V. vs Commissioner of Domestic taxes, Appeal # 343 of 2019).

Well, the Kenyan motives boil down to the fact that the interest in the production sharing agreement has the characteristics of marketability, despite the fact that the investor already pays rent and value added tax on the products.

Monday, May 4, 2026

Environmental management in production sharing agreements

The environmental management system in production sharing agreements can be conditionally divided into three independent groups:

- climatic;

- monitoring and analytical;

- transboundary.

Climatic conditions include:

- data on the state of fauna;

- data on the state of flora;

- data on biodiversity;

- data on reclaimed land;

- data on the state of greenhouse gases;

- data on archaeological heritage;

- data on landscape.

The monitoring and analytical groups include:

- direct and any indirect impact;

- indirect and cumulative impact;

- short-term, medium-term and long-term impact;

- permanent and temporary;

- positive and negative impact caused by

a) the implementation of preparatory and construction works;

b) the implementation of the planned activity, including (if necessary) dismantling work after the completion of such activity;

c) the use of natural resources, in particular land, soil, water and biodiversity, in the process of implementing the planned activity;

d) emissions and discharges of pollutants, noise, vibration, light, heat and radiation pollution, radiation and other impact factors, as well as the implementation of operations in the field of waste management.

Transboundary impact covers:

- any effects of the planned

- activity on the environment;

- any effects on health;

- any effects on flora;

- any effects on fauna;

- any effects on air, water;

- the interaction between different factors; it also covers the effects on cultural heritage or socio-economic conditions resulting from changes in these factors.

In this context, it should be noted that "transboundary impact" means any impact, not only of a global nature, in an area under the jurisdiction of a State, caused by a planned activity the physical source of which is located wholly or partly within an area under the jurisdiction of another State (Article 1, subparagraph viii, of the Convention on Environmental Impact Assessment in a Transboundary Context).

It is interesting to note that while mineral extraction and hydrocarbon production are subject to cross-border assessment under the provisions of the aforementioned Convention, production sharing agreements are not examined for cross-border impact.

Production sharing agreements are limited to assessing impacts within national borders.

Design of pilot-industrial field development

Based on the approved technological indicators for the field development, project documents are prepared for its development (up to 5 years)...