Friday, January 30, 2026

Formulation of questions for the complex verification of compliance with the terms of the production sharing agreement

The Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine "On conducting a comprehensive audit of the implementation of the conditions stipulated by the production sharing agreement" dated December 3, 2025 approved an exemplary list of issues for conducting a comprehensive audit of the implementation of production sharing agreements.

If we pay attention to the concept of the issues highlighted in the Appendix to the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers No. 1589, it is obvious that the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine, when compiling the list of issues, was guided by the powers of the central executive authorities that implement state policy in various areas.

A production sharing agreement is the world of management, the world of administring an industry through projects and infrastructure.

Therefore, I propose my own approach to specific and comprehensive control of the implementation of production sharing agreements.

Conditionally, the block of questions for the test can be divided into 6 blocks.

Block 1. Administrative.

Administrative block issues:

- the fact of registration of the operator (investor) as a taxpayer;

- the presence of a Special Permit for the extraction of minerals and payment of its cost;

- the fact of registration, the fact of the existence of rights to land plots, the use by the operator (investor) of wells that are state-owned or owned by persons in which the State owns, directly or indirectly;

- conclusion of an agreement on the engagement of an audit entity;

- confirmation of qualifications of contractor personnel;

- determining the share of jobs provided to Ukrainian citizens.

Block 2. Financial

Financial blocks issues:

- payment of bonuses in favor of the State and bonuses for signing a production sharing agreement;

- redistribution of costs;

- purchase of foreign currency for foreign economic contracts;

- guarantees from suppliers for the use of Ukrainian equipment and materials;

- payment of the cost of social investments;

- payment of the Exploration Stage;

- payment of the Industrial Development Stage;

- payment of rent and taxes;

- providing non-refundable financial assistance and debt assistance.

Block 3. Project

Project blocks issues:

- preparation of well construction projects;

- preparation of well drilling projects;

- geological exploration work programs;

- industrial development work programs;

- budget programs;

- development of land management projects;

- communication construction projects.

Block 4. Ecology

Ecology blocks issues:

- conducting an environmental impact assessment;

- compensation for losses to forest, water and land users;

- reclamation projects;

- purchase of energy-intensive equipment;

- restrictions on work on the extraction site within reserves and sanctuaries

Block 5. Land

Land blocks issues:

- conclusion of easements for land use;

- the fact of changing or expanding the mining area;

- surveying work;

- conducting geodetic work.

Block 6. Occupational safety

Occupational blocks issues:

- conservation, liquidation of objects on the Site;

- conducting introductory, primary, repeated, unscheduled, targeted briefing on labor protection;

- providing employees with special clothing, special footwear, and personal protective equipment;

- installation of fences and barriers on the Site;

- installation of access restrictions;

- physical security of the sites;

- video surveillance, involvement of the state security service.

Thursday, January 29, 2026

Permissible deviations of geometric parameters during construction and installation work performed within the framework of production sharing agreements

In Ukraine, Soviet standards for calculating permissible geometric parameters during construction and installation work are still in effect.

In general, it can be said that the specified deviations in mining range from 5 to 40 millimeters.

Permissible deviations of geometric parameters during construction and installation work performed within the framework of production sharing agreements are found in concrete and reinforced concrete blocks. 

For them impossible:

1) displacement of the axes and cups relative to the dividing axes;

2) the ratio of the marks from the projects;

3) deviation of the axes of the columns;

4) displacement of the axes of the levers and girders along the lower belt;

5) difference in the marks of the upper columns.

The deviation of the walls of the fasteners along the radius from the center of the shaft is allowed for monolithic concrete shafts and reinforced concrete fasteners up to 30 millimeters.

Deviations from the horizontal plane of the tubing rings in the range of 20 millimeters.

Of course, construction and installation work should be reflected in the shaft penetration log.

It displays geological findings, shaft construction lines, horizontal shaft sections, and mine construction rocks.

The graphs indicate sketches of details, lithological columns, depth of occurrence, rock strength, expected water inflow and date of its installation.

The verification of rope reinforcement is determined by the deviation of the width of the knees, rope conductors on horizontal suspensions.

It is required to calculate the expected error, the pulling of the opposing faces when passing slopes from horizon to horizon.

Deviation measurements are recorded in drafts. 

Drafts that must be stored until the liquidation of individual objects and the repayment of mining operations:

-executive reinforcement profiles;

- executive and control profiles of the walls of vertical mine shafts;

- executive profiles of workings.

The settlement journals that formed the basis of the drafts are also stored with the drafts.

When working on the earth's surface using an open-pit method of developing mineral deposits:

- -nodal and linear measurements are applied;

- description of geometric leveling;

- technical leveling;

- nodal and linear measurements are applied when determining survey points.

Tuesday, January 27, 2026

The place of production sharing agreements in the regulation of the provisions of the Subsoil Code of Ukraine

Despite the fact that production sharing agreements are subject to basic regulation in accordance with the Law of Ukraine “On Production Sharing Agreements” No. 1039-XIV dated September 14, 1999, the Code of Laws on Subsoil of Ukraine No. 132/94 -VR dated July 27, 1994 pays no less attention to regulation than the relevant Law No. 1039-XIV.

Conceptually, the Code of Laws on Subsoil of Ukraine should have regulatory precedence (take a higher place) than the Law of Ukraine "On Production Sharing Agreements", but it is still too early to declare it superior.

Even in matters of project and program formation, the texts of production sharing agreements retain a certain autonomy.

If the concluded production sharing agreement deviates from the provisions of the Law of Ukraine "On Production Sharing Agreements", then what should be done if the content of the production sharing agreement contradicts the Subsoil Code?

The more a specialist becomes absorbed in mining practice, the greater the theoretical gap becomes.

For example, Ukraine has not defined the place and role of legal regulation of production sharing agreements.

The Law of Ukraine "On Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of Ukraine on Updating the National Program for the Development of the Mineral and Raw Materials Base of Ukraine for the Period Until 2030 and Regulating Certain Issues Regarding Minerals and Components of Strategic and Critical Importance" No. 4154-IX of 18.12.2024  expands the categories of investors by their affiliation to registration in member countries of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.

This provision is absent from the Law of Ukraine "On Production Sharing Agreements".

How to distinguish between the Law of Ukraine "On Production Sharing Agreements" and the Code of Laws on Subsoil in order to overcome the inconsistency?

If we turn to the place of regulation of production sharing agreements, then according to the content of the Law of Ukraine "On Production Sharing Agreements", production sharing agreements are located in the coordinates of civil regulation (commercial regulation), the sphere of private law.

If we examine the architecture of the Code of Laws on Subsoil, then the Code as a regulatory legal act is of an administrative nature.


Monday, January 26, 2026

Tips for bidders on concluding production sharing agreements

Ukraine has planned a significant number of tenders for production sharing agreements in 2026.

Given that Ukraine has gained its first experience in concluding production sharing agreements for metallic minerals, it is possible to outline the approaches of the Government Commission to determine the winner.

Thus, all applications from investors are compared with each other according to the following criteria:

- geological study;

- drilling volume;

- reserve expansion scenario;

- exploration depths;

- minimum guaranteed investment volume;

- mine construction capacity;

- -mineral enrichment;

-construction of concentrate processing plants.

Among the documents attached to the application for participation in the competition, the following are of great importance:

- construction of a three-dimensional model of the mining areas;

- schedules of completed works;

- preliminary estimates for each type of work.

You should not propose technologies in your application that do not allow you to assess the realism of the solution.

It should be noted that for production sharing agreements, an important role in terms of technicality and manufacturability of production solutions is played by:- construction of shafts for mass transportation;

- creation of a digital model of the shaft;

- selective mining and crushing;

- ventilation system, loaders and dump trucks.

The state's profitability is ensured through a growing share of investment return and an increase in the cumulative economic effect.

The level of localization of production of equipment for primary extraction and mineral enrichment is the basis for the implementation of the production sharing agreement.

Tuesday, January 20, 2026

Surveying works in production sharing agreements

 Surveying works in production sharing agreements consists of:

- construction of reference and survey grids of ground surfaces;

- aerial survey of mountain cuttings;

- construction of mine shafts;

- observation of deformation of the earth's surface in the form of stations.

Geodetic signs are installed in the form of pyramids and signals. Acts on the acceptance of geodetic points are signed by the manager.

Topographic plans must display symbols (all terrain features), situations, reliefs, depressions, and outcrops of rock.

Land surveying works during land reclamation include:

- preparation of graphics;

- executive survey of reclamation;

- drawing up of the initial plan of the earth's surface;

- method of mining development.

To obtain plans of large areas, mensural and tacheometric surveys are used. Plans are updated in a desk-based manner.

When constructing hydraulic dumps, surveying work includes:

- transferring the design position to nature;

- monitoring compliance with parameters;

- periodic surveying of barrier buildings.

Surveying of quarries is carried out by the method of tachometric surveying. Surveying support of drilling works includes:

- projects from stereophotographic lines;

- transfer of control wells;

- appointment of the hydroneedle method of thawing frozen rocks.

Monday, January 19, 2026

The cheapest production sharing agreement

In the archives of the United States of America, one can find interesting government transcripts that related to the commercial activities of American companies abroad.

There are even some documents that were once confidential and related to production sharing agreements.

So, today the Memorandum of Conversation, by Richard Funkhouser of the Office on Near Eastern Affairs (Foreigner Relation of the United States, 1951, The Near East and Africa, Volume V 886А.2553/1-1051) has been published.

The Saudi Arabian government explained the need for changes because, in conditions of low oil prices, double taxation, and oil transit costs, there is no profitability at all for the government, as the other party to the production-sharing agreement.

Although the diplomatic corps of the US and Saudi Arabia have agreed to a joint meeting with the management of the American-Arab company for negotiations and agreements, this is the first case of "cheapening" a production sharing agreement.

Later, Saudi Arabia choose concessions as a tool for hydrocarbon production, but the problems were not solved.

To this day, petitions to the US Supreme Court from Saudi Arabia to review the decisions of arbitration institutions regarding the payment of awards can be found on the Internet (№ 21-1335, Saudi Arabian Oil Company).

It is obvious that at the time of concluding the production sharing agreement (1948-1951), the parties did not calculate the key contradictions that may arise during the distribution of production, did not regulate the peculiarities of production on the site, did not take into account the rent and the return of compensation costs in the share of the produced production.

Ukraine, as a party to the production sharing agreement, currently looks attractive and promising.

Investors face minimal problems with the technical aspect of implementing the production sharing agreement.

We invite you to invest in Ukrainian subsoil!

Friday, January 16, 2026

Forced expropriation of land plots from investors (operators) of production sharing agreements

In cases where the owners of the land plots refused to participate in the procedure for the purchase of land plots for the needs of hydrocarbon extraction, state authorities and local governments have the right to initiate administrative lawsuits for the forced alienation of land plots.

A positive practice of expropriating land plots from private ownership for mineral extraction has been formed in Ukraine.

The analysis used the Resolutions of the Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal (case No. 872/2а-5/16 dated March 24, 2016), (case No. 872/2а-43/15 dated June 9, 2015), (case No. 872/2а-4/14 dated January 15, 2015).

No less important is the practice of the Kharkiv District Administrative Court (case No. 820/13397/13-a dated 12/27/2013).

I propose to briefly consider the conclusions for each case.

№ 872/2а-5/16: "public necessity is determined by national interests for which forced alienation of a land plot is permitted. The enterprise is a leader in the extraction, enrichment and processing of manganese ore, employing 5,000 workers. Further uninterrupted operation of the local enterprise requires expansion of its boundaries".

No. 872/2а-43/15: "the specified land plot is located within the mining concession, within which there are deposits of manganese ores. Manganese ore, according to the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine dated 12.12.1994 No. 827, is included in the list of minerals of national importance".

No. 872/2а-4/14: "the valuation carried out in connection with the redemption for public needs is carried out on the basis of the methodological approach of capitalization of net operating or rental income from the use of land plots."

No. 820/13397/13-a: "the court disagrees with the arguments of the claim regarding the violation of public needs in this case when buying out a land plot, citing the fact that only the state or a territorial community (state or municipal enterprise) can initiate the purchase.

The Court notes that the Law in no way delimits or distinguishes objects related to the extraction of minerals by form of ownership, but only states the existence of a connection between such an object and such extraction".

The importance of correspondence in production sharing agreements

Fulfillment of the terms of a production sharing agreement requires communication between the investor (operator) of the production sharing agreement and the State government.

Official communication between the state and investors is carried out through correspondence and protocols, in which proposals submitted for consideration from investors (operators) of production sharing agreements are approved or rejected.

A completely legitimate question. What is the legal significance of the correspondence between the parties to a production sharing agreement?

Let's try to find the answer together. In arbitration practice, there is a doctrine of legitimate expectations.

The essence of this doctrine is that one party to an investment agreement performs without prejudice the obligations arising from the agreement and the obligations derived from them, which the other party to the investment agreement rightfully expects to be implemented.

The doctrine of legitimate expectations is applied in public law and does not apply in a private dispute between parties who do not expect any assistance from a government body.

The doctrine of legitimate expectations cannot be mistakenly identified with the principle of sufficient expectations, which crystallizes with the contractual context.

In such cases, any documents submitted in compliance with the doctrine of legitimate expectations are considered inadmissible.

It is not exclusive that this aspect cannot but concern correspondence in principle.

However, the phenomenon of production sharing agreements is that this group of investment agreements is of a public-private nature.

At the same time, production sharing agreements are not part of the public-private partnership sphere.

That is why correspondence constitutes an important evidentiary base.

In view of the following, it should be assumed that:

- production sharing agreements are large projects and are built on a long-term partnership;

- production sharing agreements are implemented in stages;

- the terms of the production sharing agreement are confirmed by the parties simultaneously;

- the state assumes the function of control.

Thus, the clarification of the performance of сonditions of the production sharing agreements will be reflected in the correspondence, which is formally part of the production sharing agreement.

Thursday, January 15, 2026

Coordination of the essential terms of agreements for the use of wells

Registration of passports for the use of wells is assigned to subsoil users and recorded in the State Registers (it means artesian or oil and gas registers).

When providing a field site for use under a production sharing agreement, active subsoil users of wells must transfer the wells for use to investors (operators) of the production sharing agreement.

Considering that the acquisition of wells for use by subsoil users is on a paid basis, investors (operators) of production sharing agreements are offered to reimburse the cost of transferring the wells for use.

Typically, the above-mentioned costs of investors (operators) under production sharing agreements are reimbursed by the State, as a party to the production sharing agreement, from a portion of the profitable hydrocarbons.

A logical question arises: what conditions for a well should be considered acceptable for both the well subsoil user and investors (operators) under production sharing agreements?

I propose a model for coordinating contracts for the use of wells, which is justified by the practice of a production sharing agreement.

Purpose of well use (reclamation, restoration, overhaul, geological study, additional exploration, development).

Subject of the well use agreement - temporary free use.

The term of the agreement for temporary use of wells is up to 20 years.

Automatic extension (prolongation) of the contract - on the same terms.

Well conditions - no restrictions, no encumbrances from third parties.

Terms of well transfer - according to a two- or three-party transfer-acceptance act.

Technical condition of wells - photo assessment.

Well infrastructure - the presence of access roads or public roads.

The cost of wells - based on the results of an independent assessment.

Well insurance - none. Well insurance is provided as part of general insurance by investors (operators) of production sharing agreements.

Annual maintenance fee - a small certain percentage from evaluation well amount charge.

Wednesday, January 14, 2026

Features of the transfer of land plots and rights to them to investors under production sharing agreements

The State's obligation in production sharing agreements is to provide investors with land plots and rights to them.

Ensuring the provision of land rights to investors under production sharing agreements is carried out in two ways:

- withdrawal of land plots from the land bank that are in state ownership;
- assistance in providing investors with rights to land plots that are in municipal or private ownership.

Providing investors with land plots will mean the State's fulfillment of conditions for investors to drill new wells, re-liquidation (capital repairs).

In the first case, the administrator of the production sharing agreement freely withdraws land from state ownership, while the process of granting rights to land plots from private and communal ownership is somewhat more complicated. 

Assistance in granting investors rights to land plots by the State consists of collecting information about land plots, conducting negotiations and providing proposals to investors.

The issue of securing rights to land plots for investors is somewhat more complicated in the event that private individuals and users of municipal property refuse to transfer land plots to investors for the implementation of production sharing agreements.

If private individuals (users) of municipal property refuse to provide investors with land plots, the State of Ukraine has the right to implement the redemption procedure.

Іn accordance with clause 34 of part 1 of article 26 of the Law of Ukraine "On Local Self-Government in Ukraine", the following issues are resolved exclusively at plenary meetings of the village, settlement, and city councils: resolution of issues regulating land relations in accordance with the law.

In this case, the redemption price is the value of the land plot (part thereof), taking into account the losses incurred by the owner as a result of the redemption of the land plot, including losses that will be incurred by the owner in connection with the early termination of his obligations to third parties, in particular, lost profits.

The amount of the redemption price is approved by a decision of the executive body or local government body that carries out the redemption of the land plot, or is established by a court decision.

If the owner opposes the alienation of his real estate based on the valuation conducted by the valuation entity, the authorities may engage another valuation entity to determine the value of the real estate or review the valuation report of such property.

Decisions on the redemption of land plots are made by executive authorities or local self-government bodies on the basis of general plans of settlements and other urban planning documentation, materials approving the location of such objects, land management projects regarding the allocation of a land plot.

In the event of a decision to purchase, the allocation of such a part into a separate land plot is carried out according to the relevant technical documentation with land management, the basis for the development of which is the notarized consent of the land owner to the division of the land plot or a court decision.

The information (written notice) is sent to the owner(s) of the land plot by registered letter with return receipt requested or is delivered to him/her personally against receipt.

If the owner(s) of the land plot consent to negotiations regarding the terms of their redemption, representatives of the body that made the decision to redeem them shall negotiate with the owner(s) of the land plot regarding the redemption price, terms, and other redemption terms.

If an agreement is reached to purchase a land plot, the parties enter into a purchase and sale agreement (another transaction involving the transfer of ownership).

If, within one year from the date of making the decision to purchase the land plot, a purchase and sale agreement (other transaction involving the transfer of ownership) is not concluded with the owner of the land plot, such decision becomes invalid.

It should be noted that the disagreement of the owner of the land plot with the redemption price is not a basis for recognizing the decision to redeem the object by the authorities as unlawful and canceling the specified decision, since the owner has the right to negotiate with the authorities regarding the redemption price and not agree to the sale of the object.

Thus, investors in production sharing agreements should feel confident that their rights to the land will be secured.

Monday, January 12, 2026

Deadline for conducting a comprehensive review of the implementation of the terms of the Production Sharing Agreements

In accordance with paragraph four of part one of Article 28 of the Law of Ukraine “On Production Sharing Agreements”, on December 3, 2025, the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine adopted Resolution No. 1589 “On conducting a comprehensive review of the fulfillment of the conditions stipulated by the production sharing agreement” (hereinafter referred to as the Resolution).

During the processing of comments by interested central executive bodies and government committees of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine to the draft act of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on comprehensive inspections, prepared by the Ministry of Energy of Ukraine, the proposed wording underwent significant changes, which caused legal uncertainty, different interpretations and inconsistencies.

Thus, within the meaning of Resolution No. 1589, the concept of "investor", including the operator of the Production Sharing Agreement, is considered to be persons defined by paragraph two of Article 1 of the Law of Ukraine "On Production Sharing Agreements" and who have acquired the rights and obligations defined by the agreement, or in accordance with paragraph 2 of Article 9 of the Law, are appointed by investors as the operator of the agreement to represent their interests in relations with the state.

The use of the connecting conjunction "and" used in Resolution No. 1589 provides linguistic grounds to state that the conjunction "and" in the text of Resolution No. 1589 indicates connecting and enumerative semantic relations regarding investors (operators) (it is about their acquisition of rights and acquisition of obligations).

In turn, according to Resolution No. 1589, “a comprehensive inspection of the fulfillment of the conditions stipulated by the Production Sharing Agreement (hereinafter referred to as the comprehensive inspection) is a measure of state control over the fulfillment of the conditions stipulated by the Production Sharing Agreement.

That is, the key conditions for a comprehensive audit of investors (operators) in terms of their compliance with the provisions of the Agreement are to clarify, before the start of the implementation of comprehensive audit measures, the scope of rights and obligations simultaneously acquired by investors (operators), as well as to analyze the text of Production Sharing Agreements to determine (calculate the period for conducting a comprehensive audit), since the procedure for conducting a comprehensive audit does not apply to relations arising as a result of the exercise of state supervision (control) by executive authorities in the field of economic activity.

Therefore, Production Sharing Agreements may define the criteria for starting the Production Sharing Agreement differently, which affects the determination of the term and period for conducting a comprehensive review of the implementation of the terms of the Production Sharing Agreements.

Thursday, January 8, 2026

Changes to the Procedure for the Use (Sale) of Part of the Produced Products Remaining in the Ownership of the State in Accordance with the Production Sharing Agreement (Natural Gas)

According to the Law of Ukraine "On Production Sharing Agreements", profitable production is a part of the produced production that is distributed between the investor and the state and is defined as the difference between the produced and compensatory production.

Clauses 13 and 14 of the Procedure for the use (sale) of part of the produced products that remains in the ownership of the state in accordance with the production sharing agreement (natural gas), approved by the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine dated February 9, 2024 No. 169 (hereinafter referred to as the Procedure), provide for the investor to submit and sign an act on the conformity of the shares of the produced products by the State Service for Geology and Mineral Resources of Ukraine, no later than the 20th day of the month following the calendar quarter, which includes datas:

-on the volumes (quantity) of the produced products;

- volumes (quantity) compensatory;

- profit share, including the share that remained in the ownership of the state in kind as a result of the distribution in the relevant calendar quarter;

- the accounting value of the produced products.

The act of conformity of the shares of the produced products is calculated on the basis of data, in particular, the accounting value of the produced products, calculated in accordance with the terms of the Production Sharing Agreement.

Usually, Production Sharing Agreements provide for the use of data from international platforms, which are paid, when calculating the value of the produced products.

The accounting value of the produced products directly determines the volume of compensatory products and, as a result, the volume of profitable products.

At the same time, the Procedure for the use (sale) of the part of the produced products that remains in the ownership of the state provides for the provision by the investor only of the accounting value of the produced products for consideration when processing the act on the conformity of the shares of the produced products.

However, there is no confirmation from the state of the correctness of the calculation of the accounting value of the produced products.

That is why, in order to ensure the interests of the state and properly verify the act on the conformity of shares of manufactured products (in particular, the state share), it is advisable to amend the approved Procedure to assign the calculation of the accounting value of manufactured products to a legal entity under public law that has the technical capabilities to verify the submitted acts of investors.

Tuesday, January 6, 2026

Problematic issues of purchasing insurance services in production sharing agreements

It is not possible to start hydrocarbon production without concluding a civil liability insurance contract for damage caused to the environment.

On the one hand, this is a violation of the terms of the production sharing agreement, on the other hand, it is a risk of one's own investment activities.

What are the current concerns of investors in production sharing agreements? Risk minimization through buy-out or by entering into a Loss Portfolio Transfer Agreement (LPT), the amount of insurance coverage, and requirements for reinsurers by rating agencies.

The most common mistake made by production sharing agreement designers is to incorporate valuation rules and methodologies that are used in capital markets.

The market for production sharing agreements is special in that it retains its individuality.

For example, the standard for purchasing civil liability insurance services for environmental damage should be selected based on thematic specifics.

There is no universality in civil liability insurance for damage caused to the environment, since one must choose one of 3 risks to form one's own methodology:

- pollution risk;

- national damage risk;

- property damage risk.

Civil legal damage caused to the environment as a result of mining activities in the aspect of production sharing agreements is assessed from the point of view of economic transparency, which is currently not possible to calculate.

Generalized uncertainty, information asymmetry in the legal structure of insurance under production sharing agreements is a typical phenomenon inherent in the work of an insurance company.

It is a blatant mistake to include PSAs in the terms and conditions for an insurance company through reinsurance market capitalization and credit rating standards.

Production Sharing Agreements:

- are not affected by social inflation;

- are latent in geopolitical conflicts;

- have minimal impact on climate change;

- are not subject to trade disputes

Saturday, January 3, 2026

Coalbed gas (methane) as an unconventional hydrocarbon in production sharing agreements

Coalbed methane gas production under production sharing agreements is permissible as shale gas production, central-basin gas production or oil production, or condensate production occurring in unconventional reservoirs.

Coal bed gas (methane) extraction is the extraction of coal bed gas (methane) from coal seams, host rocks, and underground cavities of operating mines, as well as depleted coal deposits, if the extracted gas (methane) is intended for further use as a material and/or energy resource.

Geological exploration, as well as the extraction of gas (methane) from coal deposits, are conditioned by the following objective conditions:

-the lack of guaranteed availability of gas (methane);

-the technological complexity of the industrial extraction and use of gas (methane) from coal deposits;

-the increased explosion and fire hazard of gas.

The main directions of development in the field of coalbed gas (methane) use are its use as a material and/or energy resource:

-at the extraction site;

-by delivering it to the end consumer via gas transportation networks, including as a mixture with natural gas.

The right to extract gas (methane) from coal deposits during degassing of operating mines is granted to the holder of a special permit for the industrial development of a coal deposit within the relevant mining concession.

The holder of a special permit for the industrial development of a coal deposit within the relevant mining concession may engage specialized organizations to perform work on the extraction of gas (methane) from coal deposits, provided that they have the relevant permits.

It is not allowed to operate coal deposits with an elevated level of gas (methane) concentration without taking the necessary ventilation or degassing measures.

The development of new coal deposits is not allowed without carrying out the necessary degassing measures in the presence of gas-saturated coal seams.

Until the conclusion of a production sharing agreement (re-issuance of a special permit by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine), a special permit for geological exploration and extraction of gas (methane) from coal deposits is granted by the State Service of Geology and Subsoil of Ukraine in agreement with the Ministry of Energy of Ukraine.

Within the boundaries of the area that does not coincide with the boundaries of the mining concession of operating mines, as well as for mines that are being prepared for operation, a special permit for geological study and extraction of gas (methane) from coal deposits is granted by the State Service of Geology and Subsoil of Ukraine without approval from the Ministry of Energy of Ukraine.

A special permit for geological exploration and extraction of gas (methane) from coal deposits whose industrial development has not been carried out regardless of their further use, as well as for depleted coal deposits, is granted for a period of no more than 20 years.

Within the framework of the regulation of production sharing agreements, a special permit for the geological study and development of coal gas (methane) deposits increases the validity period by more than 20 years (up to 50 years).

Extraction of gas (methane) from coal deposits within the mining concessions of operating mining enterprises is carried out under a separate special permit issued by the State Service for Geology and Mineral Resources of Ukraine:

-to the holder of a special permit for the industrial development of a coal deposit (subsoil user) within the relevant mining concession. This special permit is an integral part of the main special permit for the industrial development of a coal deposit (subsoil user) within the relevant mining concession and is issued for the term of the main special permit;

-to another applicant business entity within the mining concessions of operating mines only with the written consent of the subsoil user.

In the event that another business entity is granted a special permit for geological exploration and extraction of gas (methane) from coal deposits within the relevant mining concession, the subsoil user and such business entity shall enter into a civil law agreement on coordination of economic activities.

The technical conditions determined by the subsoil user in accordance with part five of this article are essential conditions of such an agreement. The agreement is subject to state registration by the State Service for Geology and Subsoil Affairs no later than two weeks from the date of its submission.

Registration of land allotments for the placement of equipment for the purpose of drilling wells for the extraction of gas (methane) from coal deposits is carried out according to a simplified procedure.


Friday, January 2, 2026

Legislative features of uranium ore mining and processing activities in Ukraine

Legal relations in the extraction, processing of uranium ores and the use of their processing products as raw materials for the production of nuclear material are regulated by the Law of Ukraine No. 645/97 of November 19, 1997.

The main objectives of this Law are the issues of:

-state regulation of safety in connection with the impact of ionizing radiation;

-state control;

-social protection of workers at uranium facilities;

-duties and responsibilities of enterprises, institutions, organizations, as well as workers at uranium facilities.

Uranium ores extracted from the subsoil and products of their processing are the property of mining and processing entities of all forms of ownership, unless otherwise established by a state order and international treaties of Ukraine.

Uranium ores and products of their processing are purchased under state order at contractual prices that ensure a level of profitability not lower than the minimum.

Property complexes of uranium facilities can be in different forms of ownership.

The activities of enterprises engaged in the extraction, processing, and transportation of uranium ores and their processing products are carried out on the basis of licenses.

Special permits for the experimental and industrial development of uranium deposits and the extraction of uranium ores are granted in agreement with the central executive body implementing state policy in the field of health care.

Special permits for the experimental and industrial development of uranium deposits and the extraction of uranium ores must contain requirements for ensuring the protection of personnel, the population, and the environment, taking into account the impact of radon and its daughter products, as well as preventing radioactive contamination of the environment.

Special permits for the construction of new uranium ore processing facilities and the reconstruction of existing facilities are granted only after receiving a positive conclusion on the environmental impact assessment of the work project.

Export and import of uranium ores and their concentrates is carried out only by legal entities under special permits, which are granted in accordance with the procedure established by the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine.

A special permit for the export of uranium ores or their concentrates to non-nuclear weapon states may be granted only if there are official commitments from the authorized state body of the importing state that the materials obtained, as well as nuclear materials produced on their base:

-will not be used for the production of nuclear weapons or other nuclear explosive devices;

-will be provided with physical protection;

-will be re-exported or transferred from the jurisdiction of the importing country to any other country.

A special permit for the export (import) of uranium ores or their concentrates may be granted on a one-time basis (per batch of goods) or for the export to one country (import from one country) of a certain quantity of goods for a certain period for a term of no more than three years.

Extracted uranium ores and their processing products (uranium concentrate, off-balance ore dumps, tailings ponds) are subject to state accounting.

Enterprises for the extraction and processing of uranium ores and users of their products are required to keep records of uranium ores and their processing products and submit reports on this.

The design of a uranium facility must include:

-an economic justification for the feasibility of implementing this project;

-measures to reduce radon emissions;

-measures for the safe storage and processing of radioactive waste.

Uranium ores can be transported in unpackaged form.

Costs associated with the cessation of uranium facilities, which include funds for decontamination, land reclamation, tailings storage facilities, and control in the sanitary protection zone and surveillance zone, are included in production costs.

Thursday, January 1, 2026

Theoretical problems of liability insurance for damage to nature in production sharing agreements

One of the essential obligations of investors is the obligation to insure the risks of causing damage to the environment and people's property under the terms of current legislation and under the terms of concluded production sharing agreements.

In Ukraine, insurance legislation was reformed in 2021, and insurance changes and innovations were launched in 2024.

Thus, Article 4 of the Law of Ukraine "On Insurance" No. 1909-IX dated September 18, 2021 introduced 23 classes, and the list of risks for them, characteristics and qualifying determinants for concluding contracts are determined by the Regulator in its regulatory acts.

The final and transitional provisions of Law No. 1909-IX contain provisions in tabular format regarding types of insurance in relation to insurance classes.

The tabular format is made within the framework of the transitional provisions of Law No. 1909-IX itself.

The class "insurance of property against fire and dangerous effects of natural phenomena" (class No. 8) provides for a type of insurance as insurance of property risks under a production sharing agreement in cases provided for by the Law of Ukraine "On Production Sharing Agreements".

In turn, the class "insurance of property against damage caused by hail, frost, other events (including theft, robbery, robbery, intentional damage/destruction of property), except for events specified in class 8" (class No. 9) also includes a provision on the type of insurance as insurance of property risks under a production sharing agreement in cases provided for by the Law of Ukraine "On Production Sharing Agreements".

Similar provisions are contained in class No. 13 "Insurance of other liability (than provided for in classes 10, 11, 12)", which includes a type of investor's civil liability insurance, including for damage caused to the environment, human health, under a production sharing agreement, unless otherwise provided for by such an agreement.

Briefly summarizing, the legislator divided the risks of insurance under production sharing agreements into 3 classes (8,9,13), which concern

- insurance of property risks;

- insurance of property risks of the subsoil user during experimental and industrial extraction and use of gas (methane) from coal deposits;

- insurance of property risks during industrial development of oil and gas deposits in cases provided for by the Law of Ukraine "On Oil and Gas";

- insurance of civil liability of the investor, including for damage caused to the environment and human health, under a production sharing agreement, unless otherwise provided for by such agreement.

That is, the legislator followed the path of including Class 3 applicants in the license of insurers for product sharing agreements without allocating them separately.

This point of view is justified by the fact that the Regulator (National Bank of Ukraine) has not adopted a regulatory legal act on the issue of insurance of production sharing agreements, their features and limits.

However, the function of the Regulator was taken over by the former Ministry of Environmental Protection and Natural Resources of Ukraine, adopting Order No. 331 of 01.04.2024 "On Approval of the Procedure and Conditions of Liability Insurance for Damage Caused by Fires and Accidents to Territories and Objects of the Nature Reserve Fund".

In accordance with this Order No. 331, the minimum insurance amount under a liability insurance contract is twenty-five thousand non-taxable minimum incomes of citizens.

The amount of the insured amount under a liability insurance contract is determined by agreement between the insurer and the insured during its conclusion or amendment, depending on the area of ​​the territory and objects of the nature reserve fund that may be damaged, but cannot be less than two thousand five hundred non-taxable minimum incomes of citizens per one hectare of area that may be damaged.

Several questions arise from a legal point of view.

Does Order No. 331 cover property risks under insurance under production sharing agreements?

Does the regulation of Order No. 331 extend directly to production sharing agreements?

Does Order No. 331 go beyond the regulation of nature reserve fund territories?

Of course, the answer is no!

Order No. 331 of the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Natural Resources of Ukraine concerns a narrow aspect of the protection of the natural and protected fund in the context of liability insurance.

Order No. 331 therefore leaves it up to the investor to understand its content as a framework instrument for insurance.

Design of pilot-industrial field development

Based on the approved technological indicators for the field development, project documents are prepared for its development (up to 5 years)...