Friday, January 16, 2026

Forced expropriation of land plots from investors (operators) of production sharing agreements

In cases where the owners of the land plots refused to participate in the procedure for the purchase of land plots for the needs of hydrocarbon extraction, state authorities and local governments have the right to initiate administrative lawsuits for the forced alienation of land plots.

A positive practice of expropriating land plots from private ownership for mineral extraction has been formed in Ukraine.

The analysis used the Resolutions of the Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal (case No. 872/2а-5/16 dated March 24, 2016), (case No. 872/2а-43/15 dated June 9, 2015), (case No. 872/2а-4/14 dated January 15, 2015).

No less important is the practice of the Kharkiv District Administrative Court (case No. 820/13397/13-a dated 12/27/2013).

I propose to briefly consider the conclusions for each case.

№ 872/2а-5/16: "public necessity is determined by national interests for which forced alienation of a land plot is permitted. The enterprise is a leader in the extraction, enrichment and processing of manganese ore, employing 5,000 workers. Further uninterrupted operation of the local enterprise requires expansion of its boundaries".

No. 872/2а-43/15: "the specified land plot is located within the mining concession, within which there are deposits of manganese ores. Manganese ore, according to the Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine dated 12.12.1994 No. 827, is included in the list of minerals of national importance".

No. 872/2а-4/14: "the valuation carried out in connection with the redemption for public needs is carried out on the basis of the methodological approach of capitalization of net operating or rental income from the use of land plots."

No. 820/13397/13-a: "the court disagrees with the arguments of the claim regarding the violation of public needs in this case when buying out a land plot, citing the fact that only the state or a territorial community (state or municipal enterprise) can initiate the purchase.

The Court notes that the Law in no way delimits or distinguishes objects related to the extraction of minerals by form of ownership, but only states the existence of a connection between such an object and such extraction".

No comments:

Post a Comment

Design of pilot-industrial field development

Based on the approved technological indicators for the field development, project documents are prepared for its development (up to 5 years)...