Thursday, March 19, 2026

On the application of the resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine № 169 dated 09.02.2024 "Some issues of the use (sale) of a part of the manufactured products that remain in the ownership of the state in accordance with production sharing agreements

In order to regulate the relationship between the investor, the State Service of the Geology and Mineral Resources of Ukraine, which is the authorized body for the implementation of production sharing agreements, and the subsidiary "Gas of Ukraine" of the joint-stock company "National Joint-stock Company "Naftogaz of Ukraine", which is designated as the authorized person to carry out all actions with hydrocarbons, in the event of the withdrawal of the share of the state of Ukraine in profitable hydrocarbons in kind, the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine adopted Resolution No. 169 of 09.02.2024 (hereinafter referred to as Resolution No. 169).

In paragraph one of the Procedure for the use (sale) of part of the produced products that remain in the ownership of the state, approved by Resolution No. 169, it is emphasized that this Procedure determines the relationship between the investor, the State Service of Geology and Mineral Resources, which is the authorized body for the implementation of production sharing agreements, and the subsidiary “Gas of Ukraine” within the framework of the implementation of the concluded agreements on the distribution of hydrocarbons.

That is, the effect of Resolution No. 169 is extended not to one investor, but to all investors in production sharing agreements without exception (regardless of whether they belong to the list of national or foreign), and is intended not for one-time, but for systematic application.

However, Resolution No. 169 contains a special caveat that its effect does not apply only if there are contradictions between the provisions of this Procedure and the agreement concluded between the investor(s) and the state of Ukraine.

According to the explanations of the "Dictionary of the Ukrainian Language" in 11 volumes, prepared by the editorial office of the O.O. Potebnia Institute of Linguistics, the term "contradiction" means: 

1) a situation in which one thing excludes another; 
2) a situation that is incompatible with it; 
3) a situation that is opposite to something; 
4) inconsistency of something with something.

Thus, Regulation No. 169 cannot apply to investors only if the provisions of the production sharing agreement itself: 

1) exclude the application of Regulation No. 169; 
2) Regulation No. 169 is inconsistent with the production sharing agreement; 
3) Regulation No. 169 is inconsistent with certain provisions of the production sharing agreement.

Partial regulation of the procedure for selecting a share in production sharing agreements does not automatically create a contradiction with the provisions of Resolution No. 169. 

The range of possible “contradictions” is not detailed in Resolution No. 169.

Resolution No. 169 in no way contradicts the content of production sharing agreements.

The procedure for using (selling) part of the produced products, although it extends its effect to investors under production sharing agreements, however, according to the explanatory note of the Ministry of Energy of Ukraine, it was developed with the aim of effectively performing its functions in the event of the selection of the share of profitable hydrocarbons due to the state of Ukraine.

Thus, the focus of the regulation of the aforementioned Procedure is focused on aspects of the procedure for selecting the appropriate share for the state of Ukraine, and not on imposing additional obligations on investors under production sharing agreements.

In view of the above, Resolution No. 169 imposes on investors the obligation to exchange information exclusively by providing data to determine the cost, volume of actual gas withdrawals, copies of primary documents confirming investors' expenses that are subject to reimbursement, data on the volume of produced products according to the indicators of measuring equipment, as well as providing copies of acts on the conformity of shares of products and reports verified by an auditor.

In arbitration practice, the principle of rebus sic stantibus is used to determine whether there is an increase in the volume of investors' obligations under production sharing agreements.

The essence of this principle is that additional obligations are assessed taking into account the following: 

1) an extraordinary and unforeseeable event has caused an imbalance in the obligations of the parties; 
2) this imbalance is such that the performance of the production sharing agreement would be unduly burdensome for one of the parties; 
3) the event causing the imbalance must not be the result of an act or omission of the party invoking this principle.

Resolution No. 169 is not an extraordinary and unforeseen event that caused an imbalance in the obligations of the parties under production sharing agreements, is not burdensome for investors in terms of information exchange, and is not a manifestation of inaction on the part of the state.

It is also worth emphasizing that Resolution No. 169 was adopted on 02/09/2024, a date later than the date of entry into force of production sharing agreements, and, therefore, Resolution No. 169 could not fail considering the peculiarities of the selection of shares according to the content of production sharing agreements.

Until the adoption of the Procedure for the Use (Sale) of Part of the Products Remaining in State Ownership, the provisions of production sharing agreements were in effect, however, the mechanism for the use (sale) of part of the products remaining in state ownership came into effect from the adoption of Resolution No. 169.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Design of pilot-industrial field development

Based on the approved technological indicators for the field development, project documents are prepared for its development (up to 5 years)...